Home page

The Sinking

The Ship

The Survivors

The Deceased

Source Documents

Survivors accounts

Capt. Hudson's report

Capt. Pearson's report

U.S. Consul's letter

Daily Alta, CA news bulletin

  - Lodge Letters
  - Popular Mechanics, May 1903

Song about the GG sinking from 1863

Google Answers on gold recovery

Survivors of the S.S. Golden Gate

by Andrew Czernek, aczernekATcomcast.net

It is 1862 and most of the news is the Civil War, with large maps on the front pages of eastern newspapers showing the Richmond area and many battle accounts. The president is pushing Emancipation; debates are raging over whether the North has the manpower to win the war; England is debating intervention to get access to Southern cotton; and Napoleon has troops fighting in Mexico. The daily newspaper is 2 cents.

Letters take a month to arrive either overland or via ship on the Panama route. The telegraph line is complete across the country, bringing snippets of news from San Francisco. But a break in the line near Salt Lake City delays news from the West Coast for a day or two.

Suddenly the monopoly of the Civil War on the news is broken in the New York Herald Tribune. These headlines are from the newspaper:

Aug. 8, 1862

Destruction by Fire of the California
Steamship Golden Gate.

180 Passengers Lost.
Over a Million and a Quarter
in Treasure Sunk..
The Vessel Beached.
No Insurance on the Ship.
Effect of the Disaster on Stocks,
Etc. Etc. Etc.

There are various accounts of how many were on-board and how many lost. One of the problem is that in the fire the ship's records were lost, so passenger lists had to be reconstructed from Pacific Mail Steamship information in San Francisco. The habit of the day was to book at the last minute (as fares would change to match supply with demand), so the records onshore were less complete. We're aware of at least one passenger killed on the ship who is not on any casualty lists. Raphael Myers, who was going to Burmingham, England to meet his wife and two daughters, who had preceeded him. His great great grand-daughter knows that he was on the ship.

This account resurrects the lists of survivors and those lost from the newspapers at the time. The New York Herald Tribune was used for the first two reports; the San Francisco Bulletin and San Francisco Daily Alta California for a "final" list of those lost published on August 11, 1862 (and corrected with the Aug. 18 arrival of 23 of the missing).

Please note that spellings are as consistent as possible with those provided by the newspapers, but errors have been detected at every transcribing. For example, "Abel Grey" is listed in a number of accounts but it is likely Abel Guy, a San Francisco banker and merchant who also had invested in the Chavanne brothers gold mine in Grass Valley. Guy was dining together on the Golden Gate with André Chavanne when they learned of the fire, thought they were separated at the sinking. Guy would retire to Paris, committing suicide by jumping from the top of a building in 1891.

André Chavanne would drift for more than 24 hours in a pair of life jackets before being rescued.


Ben J. Holladay and servant (listed below)
A.J. Nichols
J.C. Jonghaus and wife, of Sacramento
André Chavanne
Chas. J. Fox
B.L. Schmidt
L. Seedmit
Mrs. David A. (Harriet) Nurse
G. Given (boy 2 years old)
Ellie Oceanae Wandesford Given (8 weeks old)
Captain R.H. Pearson
Abel Grey or Abel Guy*
Mrs. Thomas Gough
Mrs. Walkie
Mrs. A.E. Wallace
S.M. Murphy and wife
A.J. Gunnison
Geo. O. McMullen (lost wife and children)
Capt. James Whitney, Jr.
H. Turpilin
H. Tennent
Miss Addie A. Manchester (8 years)
Miss E.C. Manchester (5 years)
Frank Manchester (3 years)
C.D. Bonestel
Julius Salinger

J.T. Haywood
O. Bradley
G.F. Bierthaught
George Fulton (7 years, nephew of George Henry Fulton)
Mrs. S. Francis
P. Bessom
William W. Walker
John Jenkins
G.W. Chase
P.H. Moran
Jane C. Forsyth, servant to Mrs. A.T. Greene
Isaac L. Gear
Gesba R.H. Dorsey
Mrs. D.J. Ross
S.C. Todd
William R. Wilcox
Chas.E. Thomas
G. Maluidi
L. Sycher
G.P. Bell
John Henry Booth, 10 years
William Hamilton, Ben Holladay's servant
J.W. Neer
Mrs. S. Tralis
J. Enba, Italian sculptor
J.L. Hulse
John or Jonas (boy 4 years, possibly elder son of J.L. Hulse)
Dr. James McChesney

Father Miguel Arano
Charles A. Bedford
Father Marcellino Blanco
Jacome Bruno
Father I. Cardenas
Francis Carroll
Amos F. Clark, St. Lawrence County, NY
E.J. Clark, , St. Lawrence County, NY (brothers who had been in North San Juan running a sawmill)
Edward Duckett
C.W. Follansbie
S. Francis
Richard W. Henderson
Wilhelm Herbert
Arthur Lepper
Edward Levine
J. Sowords
Father Juan Parga
R. Perry
J. Rosenberg
Max Seligsohn
John Smith
S.P. Storms, Indian agent, Nome Cult Reservation
Wm. Henry
E.C. Bowker
Phillip Class
N. E. Emerson
G.S. Spencer
John Dillon
A. Fischer
R. Cooper
H.A. Allen
O.P. Dowling
J.M Murphy
E.K. Haskell
N.C. Morcan
R. Leslie
J.W. Woodward
J. Tisat
J.W. Beveridge
James Antoine
J.H. Mitchell
A.H. Bates
P.M. Kearney
N. Walty
S.A. Munn, Sergeant U.S.A.
B. Irvace
J.C. Garber
John Charte
G. Malendi
J.P. Bell
A.H. Gates

W.W. Hudson, Captain
W. Waddell, Chief Engineer
Henry McKinney, Second Mate
Mathew Nolan, First Mate
James Scott, Third Mate
J.K. Wood, purser
P.A. Bergerly, first assistant engineer
J.G. Whiting, second assistant engineer
Thomas McDonald, water tender
Antonio Pachero, fireman
C. Noyes, coal passer
S. Bernard
F. Warner
M. Frye
F. Field
J. Wilson
T. Connolly
Wm Brett
P. Donnely
Michael Murray
Wm. Harvey
John Corn
M. Fairchild
J. Gone
F. Howard
C. Miller
C.C. Sullivan
D. McHull
James Ennis
J. Wilson
J. Watson
M. Kelley
R. Davy
M.J. Matthews, steward
Margaret McIntyre, stewardess
Caroline Hamilton, steerage do.
Samuel Howes, steerage steward
N. McLane, baker
R. Murley, second do.
J.F. Harris, porter
F. Douglas, butcher
Edward Douglas, sailor
Thomas Riley, seaman
Thomas Keepe, seaman

George Foote
Dennis Corcoran
H. Jeffries
George Cephus
E. Duct
B. Frits
Thomas Kelly
J. Donohoe
R. Bartslur
William Joseph
J. Peterson

P.A. Ryan, storekeeper
J. McMealey, 2nd cook after galley
Michael McLane, 3rd cook after galley
C. Grey
D. Jack Morrell, barkeeper
William Morrisey, waiter

Reem R. Redden
William H. Bibson, second barber
J. McLaughlin, sailors' mess box
William Price




Revision: 6/6/2023